A living history of philosophy · A classroom role-playing game
Ancient Philosophyas a Way of LifeKing Menander’s Court
Philosophy · History · Role-play

How should one live?

Four ancient philosophical traditions arrive at the court of King Menander, each claiming to offer a better way of life.

In this classroom role-playing game, students encounter Stoicism, Epicureanism, Buddhism, and Skepticism—not only as ideas to examine, but as practices to try and arguments to defend.

Standing Buddha sculpture in the Gandharan artistic tradition
The ancient Erechtheion temple on the Acropolis in Athens

Gandharan Buddha sculpture and the Erechtheion, Athens. Historical artworks from different periods, illustrating the traditions explored in the game. About the images.

Sāgala · c. 150 BCEFour philosophical schoolsOne royal courtNo predetermined winner
The central idea

Philosophy is more than a set of propositions.

Ancient philosophical schools asked what makes a life go well—and devised ways of thinking, living, and practicing to answer that question. Their disagreements concern happiness, virtue, suffering, desire, death, and the limits of human knowledge.

This game invites participants to inhabit those disagreements: to make a case, test an exercise, confront an objection, and decide what survives philosophical scrutiny.

Four competing answers

Four traditions. Four ways of life.

Each school provides an account of the good life, a set of practical disciplines, and a challenge to its rivals. Open a tradition below to see what is at stake.

Ancient sculpted portrait head of a bearded man
01 · Athens

Stoicism

Can virtue make a person happy even in misfortune?

Live according to reason and virtue. Examine judgments, distinguish what depends on you from what does not, and meet adversity with practical wisdom.

Explore the Stoic way

Central claim: Character, rather than fortune or wealth, is the foundation of the good life.

Practice: Notice an impression before accepting its judgment; ask what an excellent response requires.

Hard question: Can virtue really suffice when life brings extreme suffering or loss?

Ancient marble portrait head of a bearded philosopher
02 · The Garden

Epicureanism

How much do we actually need to live well?

Seek freedom from needless fear and distress. Value friendship, cultivate modest pleasures, and question the promises of fame and power.

Explore the Epicurean way

Central claim: Pleasure understood as a stable, undisturbed condition is the highest good.

Practice: Distinguish natural and necessary desires from empty ambitions and unnecessary wants.

Hard question: Can a tranquil private life meet our responsibilities to others?

Stone relief showing a seated Buddha with an attendant
03 · Northern India

Buddhism

Can craving and attachment be brought to an end?

Examine suffering and its causes through ethical conduct, attention, and wisdom. Reflect on impermanence, non-self, and compassion.

Explore the Buddhist way

Central claim: Suffering is sustained by craving and ignorance, and liberation requires transforming how we perceive and respond.

Practice: Observe the wandering mind or reflect on impermanence and attachment.

Hard question: Does freedom from attachment threaten love and ordinary commitments?

Four ancient sculpted philosopher heads displayed in a museum
04 · Inquiry

Skepticism

What if certainty outruns our reasons?

Examine rival arguments fairly, expose unsupported assumptions, and withhold judgment where evidence does not warrant conviction.

Explore the skeptical way

Central claim: Intellectual humility may be wiser than premature commitment to a complete philosophical system.

Practice: Formulate a cogent objection to each rival doctrine without assuming its opposite must be true.

Hard question: Can one act responsibly without settling ultimate questions about the good life?

The sculptures are used as historical visual references, not as authenticated portraits of each school’s representatives. About the images.

Beyond the game

Continue the inquiry.

These resources offer deeper introductions, accessible books, and examples of how ancient philosophies are discussed and practiced today. Each tradition remains open to disagreement and reinterpretation.

01 · Further inquiry

Stoicism

Scholarly introduction

Books

Contemporary engagement

02 · Further inquiry

Epicureanism

Scholarly introduction

Books

Contemporary engagement

03 · Further inquiry

Buddhism

Scholarly introduction

Books

Contemporary engagement

04 · Further inquiry

Skepticism

Scholarly introduction

Books

Contemporary engagement

The Stanford Encyclopedia entries are free to read. Book links lead to publisher information and may require purchase or library access. Contemporary authors and organizations illustrate different interpretations; their views are not official positions of the game. External links require an internet connection.

Carved Buddhist stone relief portraying a stupa surrounded by devotees
Carved Buddhist relief depicting a stupa and worshippers · supplied photograph, cropped from a two-panel image
The historical setting

At the court of King Menander

It is around 150 BCE. King Menander rules an Indo-Greek kingdom in northwestern South Asia. Greek and Indian intellectual traditions are part of a wider world of encounter and exchange.

Despite his military success, Menander remains troubled by a question no political victory can settle: How should he live? Four philosophical delegations seek to advise the king and win the court’s allegiance.

History and invention. Menander was a historical ruler, and Greek and Indian philosophical cultures interacted in the region. The contest between these four delegations is fictional; no surviving evidence records such a gathering at his court.
Learning by argument and practice

How the game unfolds

Designed around a preparation meeting and a court session, the game combines close reading, philosophical exercises, role-play, and structured debate.

01

Prepare

Participants receive characters, read their sources, and prepare arguments and questions. Factions coordinate their presentations and practices.

02

Present

Each philosophical school explains its way of life and leads a brief exercise designed to make its teaching concrete.

03

Deliberate

Court members face difficult personal dilemmas. Philosophers offer competing advice, defend their reasons, and answer objections.

04

Judge

Court members announce their allegiances. Menander awards patronage, and the factions assess the quality of the court’s philosophical deliberation.

What matters most

The aim is not merely to win votes. It is to understand competing views well enough to use them, criticize them fairly, and ask whether a useful practice is also supported by a convincing philosophy.

Resources

Game materials

All the documents for Ancient Philosophy as a Way of Life are available here as printable PDFs. Read individual materials or download the complete set.

Download all game materials 15 PDFs · Gamebook, instructor’s manual, roles, handouts, and ballots
02 documents

Gamebook & teaching guide

Begin with the gamebook; use the manual to organize and run the class.

A guide to the historical setting, four traditions, gameplay, and primary-source readings.

Teaching guidance, classroom timing, role assignments, appendices, and debriefing.

04 documents

Philosophical faction handouts

Four briefings on each tradition’s arguments and philosophical practices.

Core principles, arguments, and two short philosophical practices.

Pleasure, friendship, death, and two short philosophical practices.

Suffering, not-self, compassion, and two short philosophical practices.

Skeptical inquiry and an exercise in developing serious objections.

05 documents

Character role sheets

Distribute the appropriate private role sheets to each player.

Characters and responsibilities for members of Menander’s court.

Private character backgrounds and objectives for the Stoic delegation.

Private character backgrounds and objectives for the Epicurean delegation.

Private character backgrounds and objectives for the Buddhist delegation.

Private character backgrounds and objectives for the Skeptic delegation.

04 documents

Court materials & ballots

Printable dilemmas and ballots for the court’s final decisions and ratings.

Printable dilemmas confronting court members.

Allegiance ballots for court members and royal patronage ballot for Menander.

Four faction rating ballots for the court’s philosophical deliberation.

Foldable table signs identifying the four philosophical factions and court members.

About this project

Philosophy, understood as something one does.

Ancient Philosophy as a Way of Life is an educational role-playing game intended to make ancient ethical thought intellectually demanding, historically situated, and personally engaging.

The central pedagogical wager is simple: philosophical claims become more vivid when students must defend them against serious objections—and put them into practice, even briefly.

This game is inspired by Reacting to the Past, a role-playing approach to teaching in which students take on historical roles, study primary sources, and debate consequential questions. Ancient Philosophy as a Way of Life adapts that approach for a short, philosophy-centered classroom experience. It is an independent project, not an official Reacting to the Past publication.

License & reuse

© 2026 Javier Hidalgo. Except where otherwise noted, the original writing on this website and the original game materials authored by Javier Hidalgo are licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution–NonCommercial–ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0) license.

You may copy, share, and adapt this original material for noncommercial purposes, provided you credit the author, identify any changes, and distribute adaptations under the same license.

Third-party materials: Historical photographs, illustrations, credited quotations, source translations, and other content created by third parties are not covered by this license unless separately indicated. Their original licenses and permissions apply.

Historical images

The photographs depict ancient sculptures, reliefs, and architecture associated with the Greek and South Asian worlds. They are visual references, not reconstructions of the fictional meeting at Menander’s court.

  1. Standing Buddha, Gandharan artistic tradition
  2. The Erechtheion, Athens
  3. Sculpted portrait accompanying Stoicism
  4. Marble portrait accompanying Epicureanism
  5. Buddhist stone relief accompanying Buddhism
  6. Sculpted heads accompanying Skepticism
  7. Buddhist relief with a stupa and devotees

Photographs are used to evoke the traditions and their historical settings; they do not claim to portray the fictional philosophical delegates.